The Evil Results Of Hurting The Pious, Evil Results Of Hurting Harmless Saints, Harming The Holy Is Disastrous & Woeful States In The Wake Of Evil Doing

The Story of Venerable Maha Moggallana

Chapter 10: The Stick • Verse 9

The Verse

He who inflicts violence on those who are unarmed, and offends those who are inoffensive, will soon come upon one of these ten states:

— Dhammapada, Chapter 10, Verse 9

The Story

While residing at the Jetavana Monastery, the Buddha spoke these verses with reference to Venerable Maha Moggallana.

Once the heretics met together and asked each other why the gifts and offerings to the Buddha had grown so great. They concluded it was all because of Venerable Moggallana.

Moggallana, they said, went up to heaven and asked the deities what good deeds had earned them their glory, and went down to hell and asked its inhabitants what they had done to deserve their suffering. Then he came back and told people what deeds bring such rewards and what deeds bring such pain, and so people brought rich offerings. If they could kill him, the heretics reasoned, those offerings would come to them instead.

All agreed to kill him by any means. They roused their supporters, collected a thousand pieces of money, and gave it to a band of wandering thieves, telling them that Moggallana lived at Black Rock and that they should go there and kill him.

Tempted by the money, the thieves agreed and went and surrounded the elder's dwelling. Knowing he was surrounded, Moggallana slipped out through the keyhole and escaped.

The next day the thieves surrounded the dwelling again, but Moggallana broke through the roof and flew away into the air. For two months the thieves tried to catch him without success.

When the third month came, Moggallana felt the force of an evil deed he had done in a former existence, and he made no attempt to escape. The thieves seized him and beat him savagely, crushing his bones until they were like grains of rice. Thinking him dead, they threw his body behind a clump of bushes and left.

Moggallana resolved to pay his respects to the Buddha before passing into Nibbana. Holding his body together by the power of meditation, he flew through the air to the Buddha, paid homage, and told him he was about to pass away.

The Buddha asked where he would go, and Moggallana said to Black Rock. The Buddha asked him to teach the Dhamma once more before he went, since he would never again have such a disciple to look upon.

Moggallana paid homage, rose into the air, performed many marvels as Venerable Sariputta had done on the day of his passing, and taught the Dhamma. Then he paid homage to the Buddha once more, went to the forest at Black Rock, and passed into Nibbana.

News that thieves had killed the elder spread far and wide, and King Ajatasattu sent out spies to find them.

As it happened, the thieves were drinking in a tavern when one of them knocked another to the ground. The second thief cursed him, and the first retorted that the other had been the first to strike Venerable Moggallana. Soon they were all shouting over one another that it was they who had struck him.

The spies heard this, seized the thieves, and reported to the king. Questioned by the king, the thieves admitted the killing and said that the naked ascetics had put them up to it.

The king had the five hundred naked ascetics arrested along with the five hundred thieves. He had them all buried waist-deep in pits in the palace courtyard, covered with straw, and burned, and then had the pits ploughed over with iron ploughs.

In the hall of truth, the monks were saying that Venerable Moggallana had met a death he did not deserve. The Buddha came and asked what they were discussing.

When they told him, he said that if one looked only at this present life, it was indeed an undeserved death. But in truth, the manner of Moggallana's death exactly matched a deed he had done in a former existence. The monks asked what that deed had been, and the Buddha told them.

Long ago there was a young man of good family who did all the work of the household himself, pounding rice and cooking, and who cared for his mother and father as well.

His parents told him he was wearing himself out with all the work at home and in the forest, and that they would bring home a wife for him. He said there was no need, for as long as they lived he would care for them with his own hands. But they asked again and again, and at last they brought a young woman home as his wife.

For a few days she waited on his parents. After that she could not bear the sight of them, and she told her husband indignantly that she could no longer live under the same roof with them. He paid no attention.

So one day, while he was out, she scattered bits of clay, bark, and rice-gruel scum all over the house. When he came home and asked what had happened, she said his blind old parents had made the mess, littering the whole house, and that she could not live with them any longer.

She said this again and again, until at last even he, a being who had fulfilled the Perfections, turned against his mother and father.

He told his wife he would find a way to deal with them. After giving his parents their meal, he told them that relatives in a certain place wished them to visit, and he helped them into a cart and set out.

Deep in the forest he handed the reins to his father, saying the oxen knew the way and that this was a place where thieves waylaid travellers, so he would get down. Then he went into the forest.

There he began to shout, louder and louder, until it sounded like a band of thieves about to attack. Hearing it, his parents believed they were being set upon by robbers. They cried out to their son that they were old and he should save himself and not worry about them.

Even as they cried out this way, the son, still shouting like a thief, beat them to death and threw their bodies into the forest. Then he went home.

Having told this story, the Buddha said that because of this monstrous deed, Moggallana had suffered for countless hundreds of thousands of years in hell. Even after that, since the result was not exhausted, in a hundred successive existences he had been beaten and crushed to death in the same way. So the manner of his death had matched his own former deed exactly.

In the same way, the Buddha said, the five hundred heretics and five hundred thieves who had attacked his son, who had done them no wrong, had met exactly the death they deserved. For whoever harms the harmless meets with misfortune and loss in one of ten ways. Then he spoke these verses.

The Evil Results Of Hurting The Pious, Evil Results Of Hurting Harmless Saints, Harming The Holy Is Disastrous & Woeful States In The Wake Of Evil Doing

The Story of Venerable Maha Moggallana

Chapter 10: The Stick • Verse 9

The Verse

He who inflicts violence on those who are unarmed, and offends those who are inoffensive, will soon come upon one of these ten states:

— Dhammapada, Chapter 10, Verse 9

The Story

While residing at the Jetavana Monastery, the Buddha spoke these verses with reference to Venerable Maha Moggallana.

Once the heretics met together and asked each other why the gifts and offerings to the Buddha had grown so great. They concluded it was all because of Venerable Moggallana.

Moggallana, they said, went up to heaven and asked the deities what good deeds had earned them their glory, and went down to hell and asked its inhabitants what they had done to deserve their suffering. Then he came back and told people what deeds bring such rewards and what deeds bring such pain, and so people brought rich offerings. If they could kill him, the heretics reasoned, those offerings would come to them instead.

All agreed to kill him by any means. They roused their supporters, collected a thousand pieces of money, and gave it to a band of wandering thieves, telling them that Moggallana lived at Black Rock and that they should go there and kill him.

Tempted by the money, the thieves agreed and went and surrounded the elder's dwelling. Knowing he was surrounded, Moggallana slipped out through the keyhole and escaped.

The next day the thieves surrounded the dwelling again, but Moggallana broke through the roof and flew away into the air. For two months the thieves tried to catch him without success.

When the third month came, Moggallana felt the force of an evil deed he had done in a former existence, and he made no attempt to escape. The thieves seized him and beat him savagely, crushing his bones until they were like grains of rice. Thinking him dead, they threw his body behind a clump of bushes and left.

Moggallana resolved to pay his respects to the Buddha before passing into Nibbana. Holding his body together by the power of meditation, he flew through the air to the Buddha, paid homage, and told him he was about to pass away.

The Buddha asked where he would go, and Moggallana said to Black Rock. The Buddha asked him to teach the Dhamma once more before he went, since he would never again have such a disciple to look upon.

Moggallana paid homage, rose into the air, performed many marvels as Venerable Sariputta had done on the day of his passing, and taught the Dhamma. Then he paid homage to the Buddha once more, went to the forest at Black Rock, and passed into Nibbana.

News that thieves had killed the elder spread far and wide, and King Ajatasattu sent out spies to find them.

As it happened, the thieves were drinking in a tavern when one of them knocked another to the ground. The second thief cursed him, and the first retorted that the other had been the first to strike Venerable Moggallana. Soon they were all shouting over one another that it was they who had struck him.

The spies heard this, seized the thieves, and reported to the king. Questioned by the king, the thieves admitted the killing and said that the naked ascetics had put them up to it.

The king had the five hundred naked ascetics arrested along with the five hundred thieves. He had them all buried waist-deep in pits in the palace courtyard, covered with straw, and burned, and then had the pits ploughed over with iron ploughs.

In the hall of truth, the monks were saying that Venerable Moggallana had met a death he did not deserve. The Buddha came and asked what they were discussing.

When they told him, he said that if one looked only at this present life, it was indeed an undeserved death. But in truth, the manner of Moggallana's death exactly matched a deed he had done in a former existence. The monks asked what that deed had been, and the Buddha told them.

Long ago there was a young man of good family who did all the work of the household himself, pounding rice and cooking, and who cared for his mother and father as well.

His parents told him he was wearing himself out with all the work at home and in the forest, and that they would bring home a wife for him. He said there was no need, for as long as they lived he would care for them with his own hands. But they asked again and again, and at last they brought a young woman home as his wife.

For a few days she waited on his parents. After that she could not bear the sight of them, and she told her husband indignantly that she could no longer live under the same roof with them. He paid no attention.

So one day, while he was out, she scattered bits of clay, bark, and rice-gruel scum all over the house. When he came home and asked what had happened, she said his blind old parents had made the mess, littering the whole house, and that she could not live with them any longer.

She said this again and again, until at last even he, a being who had fulfilled the Perfections, turned against his mother and father.

He told his wife he would find a way to deal with them. After giving his parents their meal, he told them that relatives in a certain place wished them to visit, and he helped them into a cart and set out.

Deep in the forest he handed the reins to his father, saying the oxen knew the way and that this was a place where thieves waylaid travellers, so he would get down. Then he went into the forest.

There he began to shout, louder and louder, until it sounded like a band of thieves about to attack. Hearing it, his parents believed they were being set upon by robbers. They cried out to their son that they were old and he should save himself and not worry about them.

Even as they cried out this way, the son, still shouting like a thief, beat them to death and threw their bodies into the forest. Then he went home.

Having told this story, the Buddha said that because of this monstrous deed, Moggallana had suffered for countless hundreds of thousands of years in hell. Even after that, since the result was not exhausted, in a hundred successive existences he had been beaten and crushed to death in the same way. So the manner of his death had matched his own former deed exactly.

In the same way, the Buddha said, the five hundred heretics and five hundred thieves who had attacked his son, who had done them no wrong, had met exactly the death they deserved. For whoever harms the harmless meets with misfortune and loss in one of ten ways. Then he spoke these verses.

Dhammapada — Timeless wisdom from the Buddha's teachings

©2026 • A digital sanctuary for reflection

Crafted with care by Neel Gaywala