Practices That Will Not Lead To Purity
The Story of Venerable Bahubhandika
Chapter 10: The Stick • Verse 13
The Story of Venerable Bahubhandika
Chapter 10: The Stick • Verse 13
Neither going about naked, nor matted locks, nor filth, nor fasting, nor lying on the ground, nor smearing oneself with ashes and dust, nor sitting on the heels (in penance) can purify a mortal who has not overcome doubt.
While residing at the Jetavana Monastery, the Buddha spoke this verse with reference to Bahubhandika, a monk with many possessions.
There was once a rich man in Savatthi who, after his wife died, decided to become a monk. Before entering the Order, he built himself a monastery with a kitchen and a storeroom, and he brought along his own furniture and utensils and a large stock of rice, oil, butter, and other provisions.
His servants cooked whatever dishes he wanted. So even as a monk he lived in comfort, and because he had so many belongings he became known as Bahubhandika, 'the one with many goods'.
One day the other monks brought him before the Buddha and told the Buddha about all the things he had brought and how he still lived like a rich man.
The Buddha asked him why he had brought so much property, when the Buddha taught all his disciples to live austerely. At even this mild rebuke the monk lost his temper. Angrily declaring that he would now live as the Buddha wished, he threw off his upper robe.
The Buddha told him that in his previous existence he had been an evil spirit, and that even then he had possessed a sense of shame and a fear of doing wrong. Why, now that he was a monk in the Buddha's Teaching, would he throw away his sense of shame and fear of wrongdoing?
Hearing this, the monk realized his mistake. His sense of shame and fear of wrongdoing returned, and he respectfully paid homage to the Buddha and asked to be forgiven.
The Buddha told him that it was not proper to stand there without his upper robe. Merely casting off one's robe and the like does not make one an austere monk; a monk must also cast off his doubt. Then he spoke this verse.
The Story of Venerable Bahubhandika
Chapter 10: The Stick • Verse 13
Neither going about naked, nor matted locks, nor filth, nor fasting, nor lying on the ground, nor smearing oneself with ashes and dust, nor sitting on the heels (in penance) can purify a mortal who has not overcome doubt.
While residing at the Jetavana Monastery, the Buddha spoke this verse with reference to Bahubhandika, a monk with many possessions.
There was once a rich man in Savatthi who, after his wife died, decided to become a monk. Before entering the Order, he built himself a monastery with a kitchen and a storeroom, and he brought along his own furniture and utensils and a large stock of rice, oil, butter, and other provisions.
His servants cooked whatever dishes he wanted. So even as a monk he lived in comfort, and because he had so many belongings he became known as Bahubhandika, 'the one with many goods'.
One day the other monks brought him before the Buddha and told the Buddha about all the things he had brought and how he still lived like a rich man.
The Buddha asked him why he had brought so much property, when the Buddha taught all his disciples to live austerely. At even this mild rebuke the monk lost his temper. Angrily declaring that he would now live as the Buddha wished, he threw off his upper robe.
The Buddha told him that in his previous existence he had been an evil spirit, and that even then he had possessed a sense of shame and a fear of doing wrong. Why, now that he was a monk in the Buddha's Teaching, would he throw away his sense of shame and fear of wrongdoing?
Hearing this, the monk realized his mistake. His sense of shame and fear of wrongdoing returned, and he respectfully paid homage to the Buddha and asked to be forgiven.
The Buddha told him that it was not proper to stand there without his upper robe. Merely casting off one's robe and the like does not make one an austere monk; a monk must also cast off his doubt. Then he spoke this verse.