Doing Good Unto One's Own Self Is Difficult
The Story of Schism in the Sangha
Chapter 12: The Self • Verse 7
The Story of Schism in the Sangha
Chapter 12: The Self • Verse 7
Easy to do are things that are bad and harmful to oneself. But exceedingly difficult to do are things that are good and beneficial.
While residing at the Veluvana Monastery, the Buddha spoke this verse with reference to Devadatta, who committed the offence of causing a schism in the Order of monks.
Once, while the Buddha was teaching at the Veluvana Monastery, Devadatta came and suggested that since the Buddha was growing old, the leadership of the Order should be handed over to him. The Buddha refused, rebuked him, and called him a swallower of spittle. From then on Devadatta was bitter toward the Buddha, and he tried three times to kill him, but every attempt failed.
Later Devadatta tried another approach. He came to the Buddha and proposed five rules that monks should keep for life: that they live in the forest, eat only food received on alms-rounds, wear only robes made from rags collected from rubbish heaps, live at the foot of trees, and eat no fish or meat.
The Buddha had no objection to these practices and did not stop those who wished to follow them, but for good reasons he would not impose them on all monks.
Devadatta claimed that his rules were better than the existing discipline, and some newly ordained monks agreed with him. One day the Buddha asked Devadatta whether it was true that he was trying to split the Order. Devadatta admitted it. The Buddha warned him that this was a very grave offence, but Devadatta paid no heed.
Soon after, Devadatta met Venerable Ananda on his alms-round in Rajagaha and told him that from that day on he would keep the fast-day and carry out the duties of the Order separately, apart from the Buddha and his monks. On his return, Ananda reported this to the Buddha.
The Buddha reflected that Devadatta was committing a very grave offence that would send him to Avici hell. For a good person it is easy to do good and hard to do evil; for an evil person it is easy to do evil and hard to do good. Indeed, it is easy to do what is harmful, but very difficult to do what is good and beneficial. Then he spoke this verse.
On the fast-day, Devadatta broke away from the Order with five hundred Vajjian monks and went to Gayasisa. But when the two chief disciples, Sariputta and Moggallana, went and spoke with the monks who had followed him, they realized their mistake, and most of them returned with the chief disciples to the Buddha.
The Story of Schism in the Sangha
Chapter 12: The Self • Verse 7
Easy to do are things that are bad and harmful to oneself. But exceedingly difficult to do are things that are good and beneficial.
While residing at the Veluvana Monastery, the Buddha spoke this verse with reference to Devadatta, who committed the offence of causing a schism in the Order of monks.
Once, while the Buddha was teaching at the Veluvana Monastery, Devadatta came and suggested that since the Buddha was growing old, the leadership of the Order should be handed over to him. The Buddha refused, rebuked him, and called him a swallower of spittle. From then on Devadatta was bitter toward the Buddha, and he tried three times to kill him, but every attempt failed.
Later Devadatta tried another approach. He came to the Buddha and proposed five rules that monks should keep for life: that they live in the forest, eat only food received on alms-rounds, wear only robes made from rags collected from rubbish heaps, live at the foot of trees, and eat no fish or meat.
The Buddha had no objection to these practices and did not stop those who wished to follow them, but for good reasons he would not impose them on all monks.
Devadatta claimed that his rules were better than the existing discipline, and some newly ordained monks agreed with him. One day the Buddha asked Devadatta whether it was true that he was trying to split the Order. Devadatta admitted it. The Buddha warned him that this was a very grave offence, but Devadatta paid no heed.
Soon after, Devadatta met Venerable Ananda on his alms-round in Rajagaha and told him that from that day on he would keep the fast-day and carry out the duties of the Order separately, apart from the Buddha and his monks. On his return, Ananda reported this to the Buddha.
The Buddha reflected that Devadatta was committing a very grave offence that would send him to Avici hell. For a good person it is easy to do good and hard to do evil; for an evil person it is easy to do evil and hard to do good. Indeed, it is easy to do what is harmful, but very difficult to do what is good and beneficial. Then he spoke this verse.
On the fast-day, Devadatta broke away from the Order with five hundred Vajjian monks and went to Gayasisa. But when the two chief disciples, Sariputta and Moggallana, went and spoke with the monks who had followed him, they realized their mistake, and most of them returned with the chief disciples to the Buddha.